People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Best crispy chicken sandwich in town! ”
“ I bought a family pizza, great staff, great tasting food, I've been coming here since they opened and I still love them! ”
“ I love Benny's! The food is great! I have never had a problem with my food or customer service! And yes they do speak English!!! There are usually 2 guys at the counter and they both speak English just fine! The pizza is delicious, i love the cheese! The French fries taste like they used to back in the day, the way they should. The sandwiches are great, but the Italian beefs don't travel well. The bun gets soggy before you get it home. Other than that, I have had nothing but great food and service! Great job guys! Keep on doing what you do! ”
“ Their prices are reasonable, the staff is nice, and they always answer the phone. I don't think they've ever not made a pizza within 30 minutes of calling. Their main thing is pizza. I'm not sure why you'd come to a pizza restaurant and get mad they don't have good burgers. They also mainly do take out and delivery. You can technically eat in but they have limited space. One of the other reviews said they had hairy food and roaches. They got an A from the health department and the kitchen is always spotless. The building is just older. ”
“ The ABSOLUTE BEST Italian beef sandwich I have had since I moved away from up north and my favorite Italian place closed in Oak Creek. Definitely, hands down stellar!! I will be ordering often. Kudos Benny's, great job. ... ”
“ Tried Benny’s for the first time in 2013 and haven’t been disappointed since! Started coming here as a local hangout and grub spot for me and the guys & overtime it just turned into a true delicacy. I recommend anyone to come in for a nice cozy GrubHub spot. The food definitely hit the spots with a variety of choices from burgers to pizza puffs. ”
“ Got their pizza for the first time in about 10 years, great taste, quality, etc. Man at the counter was nice, Inside had a classic feel to it, and the “Family” sized pizza only took about 15-20 minutes. Pricing was amazing too considering how big the pizza was, the 3 toppings, and the great quality. 10/10 definitely coming back again and again. ”
“ We enjoy the food , been there to pick up several times. We have never had an issue on the phone, never had a screwed up order, they have always been polite. Sometimes its 20-25 minutes which is nothing. the food is hot and good. Italian beef sandwiches are excellent, but always add mozzarella cheese, hot peppers, and aujus on the side, so its not soggy. Dip it yourself. I can't believe all these issues people have, .... We have been there probably 30 times and not 1 problem from, employee, to price, to food. Prices can't be beat either !. ”
Menu
Chef Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Hot Dog
Polish Sausage
Veal Cutlet
About
Benny's Pizza - Milwaukee
Welcome to Benny's Pizza - Milwaukee, a beloved culinary gem nestled in the heart of Milwaukee at 1102 W Lincoln Ave. Renowned for its tempting offerings, Benny's is the go-to place for pizza lovers and comfort food enthusiasts alike.
At Benny's, the pizza is a masterpiece. The crust is expertly baked to achieve that perfect crispiness, while the cheese is generously layered, inviting you to take bite after bite. Customers rave about the flavor and quality, describing it as deliciously satisfying, with a sprinkle of nostalgia that transcends their taste buds. With a strong reputation built since its inception, it's no wonder long-time patrons like Robby Hovde return for that "great tasting food" and exceptional service that feels like home.
But Benny's isn't just about pizza. The menu boasts an impressive lineup of mouthwatering sandwiches including the Italian Beef, heralded by Alysa Montijo as "the ABSOLUTE BEST" she’s found since moving to Milwaukee. Each sandwich is prepared with care, ensuring each bite is packed with flavor. With options ranging from BBQ Beef to Gyros, there’s something to satisfy everyone’s cravings.
Don't overlook the sides! From the crispy Onion Rings to the delightful Cheese Sticks and rich Cheezy Garlic Bread, Benny's complements its pizzas and sandwiches with an array of delicious accompaniments. The French Fries especially draw praise, reminiscent of old-school taste that makes you feel good inside.
In addition, new fresh salads, such as the Chef Salad and Benny's Salad, offer a lighter option for those looking to balance their meals. It's this diversity that makes Benny's a reliable choice for any occasion, whether you’re feeding the family or enjoying a solo bite.
Many patrons highlight the staff's friendly demeanor and quick service. Lisa Mumm mentions how they ensure every pizza is made within 30 minutes, making it a convenient spot for takeout or delivery. The kitchen maintains a pristine environment, as confirmed by health department inspections, delivering peace of mind alongside your meals.
In a nutshell, Benny's Pizza - Milwaukee is more than just a pizza place; it’s a cherished part of the community where family meals flourish, and memories are made over shared plates. If you find yourself in the area, don’t miss out on indulging in their culinary offerings that have repeatedly earned the love and loyalty of locals. Swing by or ring them at +1 414-384-5500 and treat yourself to a slice of Milwaukee's finest!
Book a table